AINAS

How we choose

Updated

AINAS answers one question for UK buyers: which NAS can run the local AI you want, and what does it cost today? This page sets out how we get from a manufacturer's specification sheet to a ranked list with a price on it, and what we refuse to do along the way. The same rules apply to every system and every brand, and none of them depends on what we earn.

Specifications before opinions

Every system starts as a record of specifications: processor, cores, NPU, graphics, memory fitted and maximum, whether memory is soldered, ECC support, drive bays, M.2 slots, network ports, PCIe and OCuLink, power supply, operating system, Docker and virtual machine support. Each field stores its source and the type of source: the manufacturer's product page or datasheet first, official documentation next, then a retailer or a credible community report where the manufacturer is silent. Where two sources disagree we keep the manufacturer's figure and note the conflict. The sources are listed at the foot of every system page.

Opinions come after the record and are tied to it. The short answers, workload verdicts and limitations on system pages are written from the record and checked against it, so a sentence that quotes a figure the record does not hold is rejected before it is published. If you spot a figure that is wrong, send a correction with a manufacturer link and we will fix the record and every page that uses it.

The four verification states

Every AI capability we list (local LLMs, Ollama, Open WebUI, RAG, AI search, GPU expansion, hardware acceleration, AI photos, AI video and surveillance) carries one of four labels.

  • Verified by AINAS: we ran it on that system ourselves and say how. This label is used only for our own tests.
  • Vendor confirmed: the manufacturer documents it for that system, in an app listing, a support article, a datasheet or an official guide.
  • Community confirmed: credible public guides or reports show it working on that system or its platform, but the manufacturer does not document it.
  • Unverified: the hardware and software suggest it should work, but we have found no confirmation. Unverified is never counted as support.

Model fit is a fourth kind of claim, and it is always labelled Estimated. A model runs on a system when the memory it can use is at least the model's file size at that quantization multiplied by 1.2, plus 8GB left for the NAS itself; it is marginal down to 1.05 times the size plus 6GB. Memory that is soldered counts at the amount fitted. These are calculations from published file sizes, not benchmarks, and we never print a speed figure we did not measure.

How the AINAS Score works

Each system gets six component scores from 0 to 100, each from a written rule. AI capability adds a base for the system's class to points for the NPU, the integrated graphics, documented local LLM support and core count. Memory follows the maximum supported: 16GB scores 20, 32GB 40, 64GB 60, 96GB 75, 128GB 85 and 192GB or more 100. The GPU score takes the better of the expansion path (a full-size slot 100, PCIe x16 85, PCIe x8 70, OCuLink 60, PCIe x4 50) and the integrated graphics. Networking follows the fastest built-in port, from 1GbE at 10 up to 25GbE at 100. Storage counts drive bays, M.2 slots and a PCIe slot. Value is capability per £1,000 of the displayed price, and a system with no current price scores a neutral 50 on value rather than being rewarded or punished for it.

A profile is a weighting of those six components. The AINAS Score is the Overall profile; each workload page ranks by the profile that suits it.

ProfileAIMemoryGPUNetworkStorageValue
Overall35%20%15%10%10%10%
Local LLM30%35%20%5%0%10%
RAG25%30%15%10%10%10%
Home lab20%20%10%20%20%10%
Business20%20%10%20%15%15%
  • The Overall profile is used for the AINAS Score on every system page, the leaderboard and general buying guides.
  • The Local LLM profile is used for local LLM and creative AI pages.
  • The RAG profile is used for private RAG and AI search pages.
  • The Home lab profile is used for home lab, AI photo and surveillance pages.
  • The Business profile is used for business pages.

A workload score starts from its profile and is then reduced when the capability that workload needs is limited (to 85% of the profile score) or absent (to 50%), so a system cannot rank for surveillance or photo recognition on hardware alone.

On a system page, each workload gets a plain verdict. A use-case score of 60 or more reads as a good fit and 40 to 59 as OK; below 40 is a poor fit. The verdict is Unknown when every capability that workload depends on is missing or Unverified, and a workload whose own capability is Unverified cannot read as a good fit on the strength of a supporting one. Unknown means we cannot confirm it, not that it probably works.

The 24-hour price rule

Amazon prices are refreshed every six hours. A price is shown as current only if it was verified within the last 24 hours on a listing Amazon reports as available to order. That is what “current price” means everywhere on the site. Anything older is withheld and the page says the price is awaiting re-verification, so an out-of-date figure is never presented as today's. Each price shows when it was last checked, and the price history chart appears only once we hold enough of our own readings to draw it honestly. Copy on the site never quotes a price: figures appear only in the live price blocks and tables.

The RRP band and the merchant allowlist

A listing can be cheap because it is a different product, a used unit or a mistake. So an offer is displayable only if two checks pass. The seller must be Amazon, the manufacturer's own store, or a merchant we have approved for that brand and market with evidence from the brand's own reseller or partner page. And where the manufacturer has published a dated launch RRP for that configuration in the same currency, the price must sit between 40% and 135% of it. A listing that fails either check keeps its history but is shown nowhere, not on the site, the deals pages or the API. Where no same-currency RRP exists (Synology publishes none, for example), only the seller check applies.

The US fallback

When a system has no current Amazon UK offer, we show its Amazon US price instead, in US dollars exactly as Amazon states it and marked Amazon US, so you know it ships from the US. We convert it to pounds only for scoring and for the price filters, at the rate set in our admin; the converted figure is never displayed. A system with no current price in either market shows no price at all.

How lists are ranked

Buying guides and workload pages rank only systems with a current price that passes these checks, sorted by the profile score for that page. Systems that fit the topic but have no such price are listed under Worth watching without a rank. An announced system is not listed at all until it has a verified offer. Each list says which profile it uses and shows its weights, next to a link back to this page.

When a page is noindex

A buying guide or workload page asks search engines to index it only when at least three ranked systems qualify, each with a current price that passes the checks above. Below that the page stays readable but carries noindex and leaves the sitemap until enough systems qualify again; season deal pages also need to be switched on. The compare tool, the Finder and the API documentation are always noindex, because they are tools rather than answers. System pages, comparisons, guides, software pages, model pages and this page always index.

What we do not do

  • No manufactured savings. A saving is shown only when Amazon states one or when our own price history supports it, never against an inflated “was” price.
  • No benchmark numbers we did not measure. Model fit is Estimated from memory, and speed is never quoted until we publish our own tests.
  • No ranking by commission. The order of every list comes from the scores and the price rules on this page; what a retailer pays us plays no part.
  • No paid placement and no sponsored verdicts. Manufacturers cannot buy a rank, a label or a review.
  • No hidden conversions. A US price is shown in US dollars and marked as Amazon US.

AINAS earns a commission when you buy through an Amazon link, at no cost to you. The affiliate disclosure explains how, and about AINAS says who publishes the site.